1. Documentation
×

Custom resource definition (CRD) upgrade safety

Operator Lifecycle Manager (OLM) v1 is a Technology Preview feature only. Technology Preview features are not supported with Red Hat production service level agreements (SLAs) and might not be functionally complete. Red Hat does not recommend using them in production. These features provide early access to upcoming product features, enabling customers to test functionality and provide feedback during the development process.

For more information about the support scope of Red Hat Technology Preview features, see Technology Preview Features Support Scope.

When you update a custom resource definition (CRD) that is provided by a cluster extension, Operator Lifecycle Manager (OLM) v1 runs a CRD upgrade safety preflight check to ensure backwards compatibility with previous versions of that CRD. The CRD update must pass the validation checks before the change is allowed to progress on a cluster.

Additional resources

Prohibited CRD upgrade changes

The following changes to an existing custom resource definition (CRD) are caught by the CRD upgrade safety preflight check and prevent the upgrade:

  • A new required field is added to an existing version of the CRD

  • An existing field is removed from an existing version of the CRD

  • An existing field type is changed in an existing version of the CRD

  • A new default value is added to a field that did not previously have a default value

  • The default value of a field is changed

  • An existing default value of a field is removed

  • New enum restrictions are added to an existing field which did not previously have enum restrictions

  • Existing enum values from an existing field are removed

  • The minimum value of an existing field is increased in an existing version

  • The maximum value of an existing field is decreased in an existing version

  • Minimum or maximum field constraints are added to a field that did not previously have constraints

The rules for changes to minimum and maximum values apply to minimum, minLength, minProperties, minItems, maximum, maxLength, maxProperties, and maxItems constraints.

The following changes to an existing CRD are reported by the CRD upgrade safety preflight check and prevent the upgrade, though the operations are technically handled by the Kubernetes API server:

  • The scope changes from Cluster to Namespace or from Namespace to Cluster

  • An existing stored version of the CRD is removed

If the CRD upgrade safety preflight check encounters one of the prohibited upgrade changes, it logs an error for each prohibited change detected in the CRD upgrade.

In cases where a change to the CRD does not fall into one of the prohibited change categories, but is also unable to be properly detected as allowed, the CRD upgrade safety preflight check will prevent the upgrade and log an error for an "unknown change".

Allowed CRD upgrade changes

The following changes to an existing custom resource definition (CRD) are safe for backwards compatibility and will not cause the CRD upgrade safety preflight check to halt the upgrade:

  • Adding new enum values to the list of allowed enum values in a field

  • An existing required field is changed to optional in an existing version

  • The minimum value of an existing field is decreased in an existing version

  • The maximum value of an existing field is increased in an existing version

  • A new version of the CRD is added with no modifications to existing versions

Disabling CRD upgrade safety preflight check

The custom resource definition (CRD) upgrade safety preflight check can be disabled by adding the preflight.crdUpgradeSafety.disabled field with a value of true to the ClusterExtension object that provides the CRD.

Disabling the CRD upgrade safety preflight check could break backwards compatibility with stored versions of the CRD and cause other unintended consequences on the cluster.

You cannot disable individual field validators. If you disable the CRD upgrade safety preflight check, all field validators are disabled.

The following checks are handled by the Kubernetes API server:

  • The scope changes from Cluster to Namespace or from Namespace to Cluster

  • An existing stored version of the CRD is removed

After disabling the CRD upgrade safety preflight check via Operator Lifecycle Manager (OLM) v1, these two operations are still prevented by Kubernetes.
Prerequisites

  • You have a cluster extension installed.

Procedure

  1. Edit the ClusterExtension object of the CRD:

    $ oc edit clusterextension <clusterextension_name>

  2. Set the preflight.crdUpgradeSafety.disabled field to true:

    Example ClusterExtension object 
    apiVersion: olm.operatorframework.io/v1alpha1
kind: ClusterExtension
metadata:
    name: clusterextension-sample
spec:
    installNamespace: default
    packageName: argocd-operator
    version: 0.6.0
    preflight:
        crdUpgradeSafety:
            disabled: true (1)
    1 Set to true.

Examples of unsafe CRD changes

The following examples demonstrate specific changes to sections of an example custom resource definition (CRD) that would be caught by the CRD upgrade safety preflight check.

For the following examples, consider a CRD object in the following starting state:

Example CRD object 
apiVersion: apiextensions.k8s.io/v1
kind: CustomResourceDefinition
metadata:
  annotations:
    controller-gen.kubebuilder.io/version: v0.13.0
  name: example.test.example.com
spec:
  group: test.example.com
  names:
    kind: Sample
    listKind: SampleList
    plural: samples
    singular: sample
  scope: Namespaced
  versions:
  - name: v1alpha1
    schema:
      openAPIV3Schema:
        properties:
          apiVersion:
            type: string
          kind:
            type: string
          metadata:
            type: object
          spec:
            type: object
          status:
            type: object
          pollInterval:
            type: string
        type: object
    served: true
    storage: true
    subresources:
      status: {}

Scope change

In the following custom resource definition (CRD) example, the scope field is changed from Namespaced to Cluster:

Example scope change in a CRD 
    spec:
      group: test.example.com
      names:
        kind: Sample
        listKind: SampleList
        plural: samples
        singular: sample
      scope: Cluster
      versions:
      - name: v1alpha1
Example error output 
validating upgrade for CRD "test.example.com" failed: CustomResourceDefinition test.example.com failed upgrade safety validation. "NoScopeChange" validation failed: scope changed from "Namespaced" to "Cluster"

Removal of a stored version

In the following custom resource definition (CRD) example, the existing stored version, v1alpha1, is removed:

Example removal of a stored version in a CRD 
      versions:
      - name: v1alpha2
        schema:
          openAPIV3Schema:
            properties:
              apiVersion:
                type: string
              kind:
                type: string
              metadata:
                type: object
              spec:
                type: object
              status:
                type: object
              pollInterval:
                type: string
            type: object
Example error output 
validating upgrade for CRD "test.example.com" failed: CustomResourceDefinition test.example.com failed upgrade safety validation. "NoStoredVersionRemoved" validation failed: stored version "v1alpha1" removed

Removal of an existing field

In the following custom resource definition (CRD) example, the pollInterval property field is removed from the v1alpha1 schema:

Example removal of an existing field in a CRD 
      versions:
      - name: v1alpha1
        schema:
          openAPIV3Schema:
            properties:
              apiVersion:
                type: string
              kind:
                type: string
              metadata:
                type: object
              spec:
                type: object
              status:
                type: object
            type: object
Example error output 
validating upgrade for CRD "test.example.com" failed: CustomResourceDefinition test.example.com failed upgrade safety validation. "NoExistingFieldRemoved" validation failed: crd/test.example.com version/v1alpha1 field/^.spec.pollInterval may not be removed

Addition of a required field

In the following custom resource definition (CRD) example, the pollInterval property has been changed to a required field:

Example addition of a required field in a CRD 
      versions:
      - name: v1alpha2
        schema:
          openAPIV3Schema:
            properties:
              apiVersion:
                type: string
              kind:
                type: string
              metadata:
                type: object
              spec:
                type: object
              status:
                type: object
              pollInterval:
                type: string
            type: object
            required:
            - pollInterval
Example error output 
validating upgrade for CRD "test.example.com" failed: CustomResourceDefinition test.example.com failed upgrade safety validation. "ChangeValidator" validation failed: version "v1alpha1", field "^": new required fields added: [pollInterval]